top of page

When Does Human Life Begin?

Writer: Jason Pluebell
Jason Pluebell
5 hours ago
15 min read

Updated: 60 minutes ago

In the first part of this rewrite of the Abortion for Christians series, we covered the definitions of both murder and abortion in the context of this issue. Before discussing any topic, semantics are very important, so using the correct agreed-upon definitions makes or breaks the discussion. Subsequently, we followed the logic and examined some techniques abortionists use and ultimately decided that abortion, the intentional killing of a pre-born human, seems to be murder. Murder is the unjustified killing of another human being. It is a descriptive and moral term that both describes an action and prescribes a moral verdict upon it---that nothing can justify it. And since abortion for any reason entails the intentional ending of a human life in the womb, it is murder by the definition of both of those terms. But there is one more thing we should prove to give us the utmost certainty to conclude without a reasonable doubt that abortion is murder. That is, whether or not the child in the womb is a human being. I touched a little bit on this in the first part, but what does academia say? What about the sperm and egg? How can we be sure the child, in the first stages, is a human being? These questions, and more, will be tackled in this part.

Once we know if, from the earliest moment, a fetus or zygote is a living human, we can then say if abortion is murder. Once again, the last part will offer a full treatment of abortion, murder, personhood, and moral standards. From here, I will come from a scientific approach, offering you what biologists say about life in the womb.


Is A Fetus Alive?

So, is a fetus alive? No, let's go back even earlier, to the moment of conception. When does human life ultimately begin, biologically speaking? By all scientific analysis, a fetus, zygote, or whatever stage you want to say, is alive and fully human. 96% of biologists agree that life begins at conception---the union of the sperm and egg---according to a study done by the National Library of Medicine by Steven Andrew Jacobs, referred to as the "Jacobs Report." There are also legal consequences for harming a child in utero for both men and women, so life rights in the womb are presupposed by the Law (even if recent legislation decides abortion is legal up to birth in some states).


"...experts' view on this matter. Biologists from 1,058 acedemic insitutions around the world assessed survey items on when a human's life begins and, overal, 96% (5337 out of 5577) affirmed the fertilization view.1

We don't even need a study to prove this, but with simple scientific reasoning. We can make an argument from the biological requirements for life to demonstrate that a zygote (the first stage of embryonic development) is a full living human. The requirements for life include 1) cell organization, and a fetus is made of a great and complex organization of cells, as well as cell divisions working actively towards maturation. Even in the zygote stage, the genome that was created at conception is being organized and copied by DNA polymerase enzymes, helicase proteins that unzip the DNA, and a host of RNA and proteins (all found in cells) that the egg contributes to prepare for the first cell division. Even at the moment the egg and sperm meet (the zygote stage lasting about 24 hours), a new genome is made, and this cell is preparing for rapid and extremely coordinated division, a requirement for life! The next requirement is 2) reproduction, and the cells of this newly formed child are reproducing rapidly after about a day of fertilization. Of course, the organism itself cannot reproduce another human yet, but it has the genetic information that is already driving its development to include those biological capacities. All it needs is time, oxygen, and nutrition. A 1-year-old cannot reproduce either, so appealing to a child's inability to reproduce is a weak and unsound argument, as we would all consider a 1-year-old alive. Actually, it would be more accurate to say that instead of the fetus being a potential human, it is a human being with mass potential.

The next requirement for life is 3) growth and development. Lo and behold, a fetus develops more complex organ systems and body parts, all beginning at that first cell division after the zygote stage. Once all of the essential body parts and organs are in place, the child only gains mass. This being is growing, and its development is more complex than you can imagine. Another is 4) energy use. A child in utero requires food to produce enough energy for itself to maintain and grow. Even at the moment of fertilization, energy is being used to copy the DNA for division. Life also needs to 5) maintain homeostasis. This is a cell's internal operating system that guarantees and maintains stable biological operation despite the constantly changing external environment and supplies. This child is metabolizing energy and rapidly growing. If it weren't maintaining homeostasis, then it would have died, but it hasn't. Therefore, it meets requirement 5 for life. It must also 6) respond to stimuli. These babies' cells, as part of maintaining homeostasis, respond to external stimuli in order to survive and navigate. As we shall also see, early in development, a child in utero gains the ability to feel pain, hear their parents' voices, move, respond to touch, taste, suck their thumbs, and much more.

The last requirement for life is 7) Adaptation and Inheritance, which a fetus does and has. Not only has this child inherited certain physical traits they will express from their genes, but also every cell of the child passes its inherited genes to each of its divided offspring. This child can also adapt, as certain epigenetic (external influences on DNA) factors determine how certain traits and systems develop over time, such as a mother's diet, stress levels, health issues, and drug use, which affect how the child adjusts to its environment in the womb and expresses its genetics. We can make this into a philosophical argument as such:


Premise 1: If a child in utero is alive, then it would meet all seven requirements for life.

Premise 2: The child in utero meets all seven requirements for life.

Premise 3: Therefore, a child in utero is alive.


A zygote meets all the requirements for life, as it has all of the essential properties that fit life. So to say that it isn't alive is to go against sound reasoning and unified human scientific experience. A child in utero, from the moment of conception, is by all measures alive, but is it human?


When Does Human Life Begin?

Life is the condition that distinguishes animals and plants from non-living matter, including the capacity for growth, reproduction, functional activity, and the continual change preceding death. From a naturalistic point of view, there is no difference between plant life, animal life, or human life. They are just varying levels of complexity, but nothing more than molecules in motion. So from a naturalistic perspective, of course, some abstract concept, such as the inherent value of human life, is nothing but an illusion, and thus can either be rejected or applied arbitrarily. There is nothing "inherent" about value, as ultimate value and truth are stance-based (determined within the opinions and stances of individuals). But Biblically speaking, humans have something extra that separates us from animal and plant life, and that human life begins at conception. In the Christian worldview, humanity is created in the Image of God, as we share in his likeness, and reflect his nature. This includes our moral motions, intellectual capacities, abstract reasoning, creativity, free will, and the capacity to be good.

Human life begins when the soul is united with the flesh at conception. Each human, from the moment they enter this world, has personhood from their image-bearing, and we will see what this means later in the series. For the secularist's sake, we will mainly leave this out of the discussion, because as we have seen, this being contains a genetic code that is unique and special to the human race. I am not undermining biblical authority here, but am seeking to settle this within the worldview/paradigm of the abortionist. They claim to hold to science, and have the scientific position... so let's hold them to that! From a scientific standpoint, this being will develop into a human being only. That is because it is a human that originated from human beings; therefore, it is a human being! From a purely scientific standpoint, if the child in utero is biologically alive, then it is biologically a human, and thus has human life. We can also construct this into an argument.


Premise 1: If the child in utero is a human life, then it will meet the requirements for life, and contain the specific genetic information classified to human beings.

Premise 2: The child in utero meets the requirements for life and contains the genetic code that is specifically identified with human beings, and is actively driven by this code to develop into a mature human adult.

Premise 3: Therefore, the child in utero is a human life at a certain stage of development.


Most people's knowledge of this topic comes from a very one-sided presentation of the facts and repeated errors about abortion. Harvard's International Conference on Abortion held in Washington D.C. in 1967 found that at "no point in time between the union of the sperm and egg, or at least the blastocyst stage, and the birth of the infant at which point we could say that this was not human life," and they continue "the changes ocurring between implantation, a 6-month fetus, a 6-week old infant, or a mature adult are merely stages of development and maturation"2 They could not find any point after conception that was not entirely human. The being is human from conception! And the Jacobs Report previously mentioned found that of about 5,500 biologists from over 1,000 academic institutions, 96% of them agreed that life began at conception.1 We can confidently say that human life does begin at conception.


What About The Sperm And The Ovum?

"But the sperm and egg are alive; what sets them apart from the fertilized ovum?" Sperm contains half of the genetic code of the father and has no other goal in its life than fertilization. Each one contains a different shuffle of the genetics and is part of his body. Each sperm will never become an organism itself, given any amount of time. The ovum contains only half of the mother's genetic code and is, no question, part of her body. Her ovum will also never become an organism or another human alone, given enough time, so neither of them can be considered a human being on their own. When the two meet, the 23 chromosomes from both join to create a unique being that has never existed before, with a unique genetic code that is undergoing constant maintenance and translation to begin constructing the body of this human. This being is fully equipped with a full package of genetic code that is preprogrammed and actively working towards the maturation and adulthood from the moment the two gametes of the mother and father meet. Nothing has been added to this from conception till death; only nutrition, time, and oxygen. The entire human being is there; it just needs time to develop and mature.

"Is it human at this point?" Well, would you say an adult came from a child? Think about it. No, you would say that an adult was once a child in the past and has since grown and matured into an adult human being. Everything the adult is was once compacted into the child that was given time, nutrition, and oxygen to enable their development. The same logic goes for the zygote, fetus, or infant. An infant didn't come from a fetus; it once was a fetus. The fetus didn't come from an embryo; it was once an embryo, and the embryo was once a blastocyst, and that was once a zygote. All of these are titles for stages of development of a human being that begin with conception from the human parents.

"Is the fertilized ovum a human life?" Some say that it is just a blueprint for a human being, or just a clump of cells (at this stage, a cell), but is this correct? A blueprint is examined, followed, and then once the building is complete, disposed of or stored away. A blueprint doesn't transform into the building itself, build the biological machinery to make it, or defend and maintain the quality of it. A fertilized ovum is not a blueprint for a grocery store, but the grocery store in miniature. Given time, nutrition, and oxygen, it will grow into a full commercial shopping complex, and then into a city, and finally into an entire continent-sized facility! This is the fertilized ovum; it is the human being, not the blueprint for it. The blueprint is the genetic code that is already there and actively working. This is not a form of animal or plant life that develops into a human life, either. Fertilized sunflower seeds will always grow into a sunflower. The ova of bears will always grow into bears. At the moment of their conception, those plants and animals are always whatever species their parents were. They never change from one life to another, but remain, if from a bear, a bear. So no, the ovum, embryo, and fetus are not considered animal life until some arbitrarily decided stage of development. Neither is it a clump of cells, as all living organisms are clumps of cells. By that logic, it is simply the number of cells you have that determines your value, a sort of Agar.io scenario. But we wouldn't dare fall down that slippery slope, would we?

Humans can only produce other humans. This is very simple and a basic law of biology. When a man and a woman reproduce, they will always conceive a human being. It is not a fish, a monkey, or a dog. A plant seed always develops into a plant of the same kind. A dog zygote will always develop into a dog. A horse fetus will always develop into a horse. A human embryo will always develop and be born as a human being. God made it this way so that organisms can only reproduce by their kind (Genesis 1:24). Genetically speaking, there is always a limitation where one kind of animal will never evolve into another, as the vast information modification, subtraction, addition, reshuffling, and reprogramming limitations are unimaginable.


Utero Development

During sex, the male ejects sperm, and they swim through the uterine cavity into the fallopian tubes and surround the ovum. The female egg (the ovum) breaks the shell of the ovary, and the sperm can penetrate the egg. At the very moment one sperm cell meets the egg, it becomes fertilized. After this, the fertilized ovum travels slowly back through the fallopian tube while internal proteins and RNA prepare the genome for cell division and specialization for about 24 hours. After it makes it to the uterus, cell division begins, and each specialized cell begins to construct the form of the child, now in the blastocyst stage. Within about a week, it has now multiplied greatly and has now been implanted within the uterine walls. Given time, nutrition, and oxygen, the fertilized ovum will develop into an embryo, and then a fetus, while remaining a human. After birth, it will become an infant, and on its path to becoming a mature adult. The sperm and egg cells themselves are alive but have reached a peak of their individual developmental potential. Sperm is a part of the father, a product of his reproductive system, and bears half of his genetic code, and likewise for the mother's egg.

Nutrition, time, and oxygen will add nothing to either cell alone, and in time, the sperm or egg will eventually die. The only way they can "continue" is through fertilization, which results in an entirely new human being being created. This new human is entirely different than the sperm and egg, and the mother and father. It has its own genetic code packed with programming for a fully developed adult human. It may live, or it may die, but it will always be a human on the path to adulthood.

"Is this single cell a human being?" A fertilized ovum will divide into multiple cells, all working towards the same goal of specialized organization and human maturation into a unified complex human being. None of us came from a fertilized ovum, but rather were all once a fertilized ovum. To say an adult came from a child makes no sense, as we have already seen. The adult was once a child, who was once a toddler, who was once an infant, who was once a fetus, who was once an embryo, all the way to a zygote. These are all titles for stages of development. To simplify our speech, we don’t directly identify the subject of development in conversation because it is most likely already in the context (hence we say “fetus” and “zygote” without specifying if it is a human sometimes). Some people play semantics here and try to trap people in their own words, but stay strong to your definitions. Accurately speaking, these titles must have an identifier or referent to complete the thought. Thus, it is a human "then the stage of development". A human fetus, a human zygote, a human embryo, a human adult. The same for all sexually reproductive organisms, a cow fetus, a dog embryo, a whale zygote. It is always a human, and has been since the beginning.


This New Being Is Unique And Unimaginably Complex

The zygote is not a simple organism. It contains a long genetic code (3.1 billion base pairs), which is brand new and in no way identical or reproducible---a requirement for life. Its development is completely independent of the mother's will (unless she decides to kill it. The father of Fetology, Sir Albert William Liley, had this to say about the complexity and uniqueness of this new being,


“...seven days after fertilization the young individual, in command of his environment and destiny with tenacious purpose, implants in the spongy lining and with display of physiological power suppresses his mother's menstrual period… the embryo develops a placenta and protective capsule of fluid for himself. He also solves, single-handed the homograft problem, that dazzling feat by which fetus and mother, although immunological foreigners who could not exchange skin grafts nor safely receive blood from each other, nevertheless tolerate each other in parabiosis for nine months… He is responsive to pain and touch and cold and sound and light. He drinks his amniotic fluid, more if it is artificially sweetened, and less if it is given an unpleasant taste. He gets hiccups and sucks his thumb. He wakes and sleeps. He gets bored with repetitive signals, but can be taught to be alerted by a first signal for a second different one. And finally, he determines his birthday, for unquestionably the onset of labor is a unilateral decision of the fetus… This is the fetus we look after in modern obstetrics, the same baby we are caring for before and after birth, who before birth can be ill and indeed diagnosis and treatment just like any other patient?"3

"But a fetus cannot survive outside the womb," you may say. A 1-year-old cannot survive apart from its parental dependence either, and we all know that dependency doesn't constitute human value. Responding to popular arguments for abortion will be covered in Part 5


Closing Remarks

Without a doubt, the moment of conception is the beginning of both life and human life. To deny this blatant biological fact is to deny a known part of reality---the essence of close-mindedness. If you find yourself brainwashed to deny this, then this should be a moment of self-reflection, intellectually and morally speaking. If murder is the unjustified killing of an innocent human life, then induced abortion is exactly that.  From the moment the sperm and the egg meet, a brand new line of genetic code is created. All packed with the programming for a fully developed human being. We would not say an adult came from a child; likewise, we wouldn't say an infant came from a fetus. The sperm and egg are not human life in their entirety, for many factors that set them apart from the fertilized ovum have already been discussed.

Biblically speaking, life begins at conception. 


"For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother's womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well. My frame was not hidden from you when I was made in the secret place, when I was formed in the depths of the earth. Your eyes saw my unformed body; all the days ordained for me were written in your book before one of them came to be." (Psalm 139: 13-16)

"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you; before you were born, I set you apart, and I appointed you as a prophet to the nations." (Jeremiah 1:5)

Moreover, in Luke chapter 1, John the Baptist is filled with the Spirit while being in the womb, displaying God's value of unborn lives. You cannot win the debate on justifying abortion by using the Bible. Neither can you with modern science. The real question is when does personhood begin? Does it start at birth? At some point during pregnancy? Or is it inherent to the baby at birth? This is ultimately a philosophical question, and it brings to the table a moral standard, which we touched on in Part 1. And in that, we saw a little bit about how, without God, you have no fixed moral standard to reference for goodness or normative behaviour. You are left with what subjects feel about certain actions, and nothing else. So when we come to personhood, and from a secular paradigm, we have no fixed standard governing when or who it applies to. And this has been exploited by men since ancient times by saying one class of people does not have personhood, a slave class, or a certain somebody who wanted to exterminate an entire people group. And abolitionists grunded peoples personhood in the fact that they bear God’s image. Infanticide and slavery were both ended by Christians appealing to human value grounded in God.

So in a secular worldview, where anything transcendent and metaphysical is rejected, you have zero room for philosophical categories such as personhood. But in the Christian worldview, personhood is ultimate, in that God is a trinity of persons and one divine essence. We have grounds and can account for personhood and objective normative laws. But the atheist does not. It is then arbitrary on their end, with no justification for things like moral laws or universally binding truths. The last part will cover the moral argument and personhood in more detail. I pray that the value of God's Image can make a true impact on you, the way God meant it to. May you accept the loving grace of Jesus Christ, and humble yourself before Him and accept the forgiveness of all sin, even abortion. May that image be refocussed on the Living God, Jesus Christ.


1 (S. A. Jacobs, The Scientific Consensus on When a Human's Life Begins, The Scientific Consensus on When a Human's Life Begins - PubMed)

2 (The Conference on Abortion, Harvard, quoted in John C. Willke, Handbook on Abortion, 1979 edition. Unfortunately, I do not have a copy of the handbook anymore, as I gave it away, so I cannot locate the exact location of this quote)

3 (Liberal Studies, A Case Against Abortion, Whitcombe & Tombs, Ltd., 1971, taken from John C. Willke, Handbook on Abortion)


Comments


bottom of page